Usability of closed comment in WordPress blog

Noted: Tuesday, August 17, 2010 at 22:03:09. Words count: 202.
Last updated: Monday, August 30, 2010 at 11:10:46.

Blog posting with closed comment is difficult to identified. Not usable in my mind. Check WordPress dashboard. Discussion setting is available in There are some options to disallow comments.

  1. In menu "Default article settings", uncheck Allow people to post comments on new articles. Users may see some texts in post meta data and comment section that comment is closed at the time. Or change comments.php file properly. But Allow comments option in individual posting may change this default preferences.
  2. In menu "Other comment settings", there is an option to Automatically close comments on articles older than [numeric] days. By default, in the blog post, no text mentioning that comment is already closed. Not usable, I think.

On this unessential weblog, all comments are already closed for sure using both of those methods. Then I chose to modify comments.php file to make it more usable. Before the line

<?php if ('open' == $post->comment_status) : ?>

I put these markups

<p class="nocomment"><em>Sorry, all responses are closed at this time. You may <a href="">contact me</a> if needed.</em></p>

And change post meta data to inform that comments are closed. So you don’t have to scroll down, waste your time, and find no more comment form available.

Dani Iswara, [myfirstnamelastname]

One comment to "Usability of closed comment in WordPress blog"

  1. Reopening comment system in WordPress is a bad experience - Unessential Side - Tidak Penting

    […] The reopening process is nightmare, really. It wasn’t usable discussion setting. Bad experience for WordPress users. Previously, for some weeks, I did a live test to check the usability of closed comment in WordPress blog. […]

Leave comment

All XHTML markups will be held for moderation. Keep on topic, please.